Determining whether it’s best for you to wear perfume or scented lotion requires a personal decision process. There are advantages and disadvantages to both.
In this post you’ll learn more about each scent option and how to determine which is better for you.
Is Perfume or Lotion Better?
There is a lot to consider when determining whether perfume or lotion is the better option for you.
From my perspective, it may not be that one is better than the other; they’re simply different. Each one carries its own purpose. Lotions soothe and moisturize the skin. Perfumes help you smell nice. Scented lotions are a combination of the two.
If you’re interested in nourishing your skin with a fragrance, then a scented lotion might be the better option. But if you’re looking for a more intense fragrance that you can sporadically spray on as desired, then you might prefer perfumes.
Benefits of Using Perfume Alone
Perfumes are highly concentrated scents that can last on your skin for a few hours up to an entire day.
Not only can they help improve your mood and raise confidence levels, some people wear perfumes to attract a partner or maintain the attraction with their current partner.
Layered perfume fragrances unfold as the day progresses. The top layer lasts up to fifteen minutes. The middle layer will last a couple hours after the top layer fades away. And then you’re left with the base layer, which is the longest lasting and most dense layer of the fragrance.
If you would enjoy this transformative experience, then you might prefer perfumes over lotions.
Benefits of Using Scented Lotion Alone
Since we’re comparing lotion with perfume, I think it best to make reference to scented lotions for the remainder of this article.
Moisturizes the Skin
The primary ingredient in perfumes is alcohol. And as you know, alcohol evaporates quickly and can dry out your skin.
When using scented lotion, there is little to no alcohol in the lotion formula. Therefore, you can moisturize your skin while releasing a nice fragrance throughout the day and maintaining proper moisture levels.
Moisture helps fragrance remain on your skin. So if your lotion’s fragranced, then you can expect for the scent to last longer throughout the day.
Complete Body Coverage
When spraying on perfume, it’s likely that you will only spray the fragrance on key areas of your body. But when applying scented lotion, you’re more likely to smooth it over your entire body.
Full body coverage means that you will smell of this fragrance from your neck to your feet. While that may sound intense, lotions are often subtler than perfumes. They’re not as concentrated, so you will probably not offend others when applying full coverage of scented lotion.
Full coverage also leads to higher sillage. Your scent trail may not smell more intense but it might be more pronounced.
One of the downfalls of using perfume is that they’re stored in glass bottles. If the bottle breaks, you’ve lost out on a high-priced accessory.
When it comes to lotion bottles, they’re built to be dropped, tossed, and handled in a less careful manner.
So you don’t have to worry as much about potentially wasting your fragranced lotion.
Possibly Less Intense than Perfume
In some cases, you may enjoy the fragrance of a perfume but find it to be overpowering. If this is true for you, then it might help to try the lotion version of the same scent, if it’s available.
Oftentimes, the lotion is milder, and you’ll be able to better tolerate the fragrance intensity.
More Lasting Fragrance
When applying lotion to your body, it will automatically transfer to your clothes as they press against your skin.
When fragrances are applied to your clothes they carry the scent in a neutral manner. You’ll smell the pure fragrance instead of the scent that’s generated when it comes in contact with your unique body chemistry.
There are a number of reasons why applying scented lotion to the body during warmer months might be more effective than spraying on your favorite perfume.
In high heat conditions, perfumes evaporate more quickly than in fall or winter.
Scented lotions might be a more economical option because they’ll remain on your skin longer. If you have to reapply lotion throughout the day, it’s not as much of an economical loss because lotions are less expensive than perfumes.
Alternatively, when it’s colder outdoors, then a scented lotion can help your skin cells to retain moisture while releasing a pleasant fragrance.
Scent Remains Static
Unlike perfumes, scented lotions don’t unfold throughout the day. Even when made with multiple scent notes, fragrance is steadily and evenly released. Some people prefer singular notes like this. Not everyone wants to be surprised by how they smell as the scent dries down throughout the day.
Simple Fragrance Application
When wearing scented lotion alone, you don’t have to be concerned with whether or not it will pair well with your perfume. It’s an uncomplicated way of fragrancing your body.
More Natural Options
Perfumes are known to include a combination of natural and synthetic ingredients that may not agree with your skin composition.
If you’d prefer to smell nice with all natural ingredients, then that’s more of a possibility with some lotions than with most perfumes.
There are natural lotions on the market that are fragranced with all natural essential oils.
Disadvantages to Wearing Scents
Those with skin sensitivities might want to steer away from scented lotions altogether.
Not only can scented lotions trigger a skin reaction, but they can worsen current skin conditions.
If your skin is naturally dry and irritated during the winter, then it might be better to apply unscented lotion because scented lotion can further irritate your skin.
More specifically, fragrance ingredients have been clinically determined to cause multiple skin reactions.
According to the European Commission, a contact allergy triggered by fragrances can lead to a number of skin reactions:
- Allergic contact dermatitis
- Irritant contact dermatitis
- Contact Urticaria
- Pigmented contact dermatitis
- Airborne contact dermatitis
- Connubial contact dermatitis
You can read more about each condition and its clinical features in detail. Researchers have found that females with sensitive skin are most likely to experience a contact allergy caused by fragrance.
But note that a fragrance formula can contain up to 300 ingredients. The least amount of ingredients that these formulas contain is ten.
If you notice that your skin is displeased with a particular lotion or perfume, you should discontinue using it. In order to confirm whether you might be experiencing an allergic reaction or sensitivity, you’d have to have a patch test done.
Dermatologists conduct the testing and after about a week, they can offer you a treatment plan.
Sometimes a person might notice slight irritation, and then continue to use fragranced products in those areas of their body. But it’s really more beneficial to take the time to see a specialist if you have access to those services.
Can You Layer Perfume and Lotion?
For an added boost to perfumes, you can apply a layer of scented lotion prior to spraying on your perfume.
Sometimes applying the lotion version of the same perfume can intensify and prolong the longevity of that scent throughout the day.
When pairing your favorite lotions with your favorite perfumes, there are a few tips to keep in mind to avoid fragrance clashing.
As a reminder, there are four primary scent categories: floral, oriental, woody, and fresh. Fruity scents are a subcategory that are a cross between floral and fresh scent notes. Citrus notes are categorized as fresh.
You might remember that oriental scent notes are spicy and/or ambery. These notes pair best with fruity and floral scent notes. They might also work with some woody notes, but you’d have to experiment first before walking out the door with such a combination.
Floral scents can be paired with any of the other three categories. Fresh notes pair best with floral notes, and secondarily with woodsy notes. Wood notes can potentially work well with any of the other scent categories as well.
Should You Use Lotion Instead of Perfume?
Perfumes have higher fragrance concentrations than lotions. So if your goal is to carry a fragrance with that level of intensity, then you might not want to replace your perfume with scented lotion.
Scented lotions are subtler – even when applied to the entire body. They also aren’t going to offer you the layered unfolding process previously described in this article.
The primary added benefit to using lotion is that it will moisturize instead of dry out your skin. Secondarily, the fragrance will likely remain on your body longer due to the added moisture element.
But both lotion and perfume can potentially trigger a skin reaction. So it’s best to choose depending on your preferences while keeping your health conditions in mind.
I hope this article helped you sort out whether perfume or lotion is the better option for you.